The above scenarios mirror disc playback perfectly.
Makemkv alternative full#
There are no forced subs so only one sub track is output, but it does not have the default status set, so VLC and Kodi do not show the full track by default, but the subs are available upon request.
I select PGS English and PGS English (forced only). Output correctly contains two subtitle tracks, second of which contains the forced subs, and this track is marked as default and is automatically displayed in VLC player and Kodi.Įpisode 1 (no forced subs in the main track). Up to version 1.14.5, behaviour was as follows:Įpisode 2 (first of many episodes with forces subs embedded in the main sub track).
Makemkv alternative series#
I will use Game of Thrones Series 1 bluray as an example. Posting on this again as I do feel there has been a functionality regression in 1.14.6/7. It would be useful to know if handling of sub default flags has changed at some point, and if anyone would object to either changing back or having this set as a user configurable option. I've not been ripping much in the last year so I'm not sure when this issue came about. Is it correct that the way makemkv handles this has changed at some point? This is a bit of a chore, as I'm having to remux now afterwards to get the flags set correctly, or just gamble that there are not forced subs, whereas before I could usually do the whole thing in one pass. This means I now get the full subs showing when I don't want them. This was perfect, exactly mirroring original-disc playback.Īt some point, it looks like things have changed so that in the event the forced track is empty, the mkv default flag is now set for the full main language subtitle track. the full subs would only be shown in Kodi upon request. If there are no forced subtitles, I'm pretty sure what used to happen is that the main language track would be retained but without the d flag set - i.e. In the rare occasions where there are forced subtitles within the main track the forced track gets the default flag in the mkv file and the subs seamlessly switch on when the mkv is played through Kodi. as common on Marvel titles, I am focusing here on the handling of forced subs embedded in the main track, e.g. (I should clarify I am very familiar on the subject of separate dedicated subtitle tracks to provide forced subtitles, e.g. My usual ripping workflow is to tick both my main language subtitle track and the forced version.
0 kommentar(er)
